Of what Permatang Pauh by election could and could not tell us

cezanne-kitchen_table_wince.jpgFrom the very beginning, the 2008 Permatang Pauh by-election is not about whether Anwar Ibrahim will win it. It is a question of how much will he win. The magnitude of his win could answer several more questions too but not all.


The first question asks whether support for Anwar Ibrahim has changed since March 8. It is tempting to link the magnitude of his win with support which he will receive at the ballot box but a person makes such connection at his own peril. The reason is that there is really no benchmark to measure this in a conclusive manner.


The kosher way of measuring whether support for Anwar Ibrahim has increased or otherwise based on difference in magnitude: this win needs to be compared with Anwar Ibrahim’s last win in the same place. This method will reasonably control noise that would otherwise drown the signal which we seek.


The problem is that Anwar Ibrahim did not contest in the last election in Permatang Pauh. Instead, it was his wife Wan Azizah Wan Ismail. And the last time Anwar Ibrahim contested there was so long ago in 1995 when the situation was very different. The very different scenes make the comparison between the 1995 and the 2008 results useless in answering the question.


Any comparison between tomorrow’s by-election and the result of March 8 comes closer in answering which voters prefer better between Anwar and Wan Azizah. Even this pretends that the effect of their opponents is practically negligible.


The closest possibly way of measuring whether support for Anwar Ibrahim has changed for better or for worse based on tomorrow result is to assume that Wan Azizah is a proxy for Anwar. The assumption of proxy however ignores any individual effect that exists.


This same assumption however cannot be used to measure how damaging all the negative politics — especially the allegation of sodomy and the subsequent oath on the Koran — employed against Anwar.


While it is true that all that attacks launched by Barisan Nasional against the former Deputy Prime Minister will have an adverse effect to his prospect of being elected into office, it is really hard to know what is the exact or even the rough magnitude of that effect based simply on result of Permatang Pauh by-election. This is especially so when accusation of sodomy is really a weapon which cannot be used against Wan Azizah: Wan Azizah and Anwar are very different for the obvious reason even if proxy is a useful statistical tool. This difference renders the proxy method somewhat unreliable than it usually is.


A better way to measure the effect of the allegations made against Anwar Ibrahim is to have consistent polling, which we probably have thanks to the Merdeka Centre. Alas, that sample may not necessarily describe the preference of voters registered in Permatang Pauh. And result from the Permatang Pauh definitely cannot be used to gauge national sentiment in a satisfactory manner.


An easier question to answer with regard the upcoming by-election is which between Anwar Ibrahim and Wan Azizah Wan Ismail do voters of Permatang Pauh prefer. Another concerns the support level of Parti Keadilan Rakyat among the voters of Permatang Pauh. In both cases, the methodology in finding out the answers is straight forward.


So, do keep these things in mind before you read any political analysis by so-called pundits. Obviously, these questions put forth are not exhausting. Neverthless, the question are useful in identifying sweep conclusion. And sweeping conclusion is the last thing we need to understand the very messy political scenario we are currently in.


Read more thoughts from the__earthinc here

 
< Prev   Next >

Commentary

CommentaryRais Yatim: Signifikan Melayu dan Pribumi dalam sejarah dan perundangan

article thumbnailHanya Raja kita yang boleh dianggap Tuan kepada semua warganegara Malaysia. Selainnya kita adalah sama di sisi undang-undang.11 Perkara 8 Perlembagaan Persekutuan mengisytiharkan semua orang adalah sama di sisi undang-undang. Berhadapan dengan...
Read more...

CommentaryThe realities of Malaysia politics

article thumbnailThere's another reality non-Muslims must understand - issues relating to Islam that does not infringe upon their rights is best left to Muslim groups. Non-governmental organisations, especially headed by non-Muslims, must learn to be sensitive. Nik...
Read more...

CommentarySejarah pengubalan Perlembagaan Persekutuan Tanah Melayu

article thumbnail Unless the provisions to be inserted in the constitution are carefully drafted, they can be interpreted to the disadvantage of non-Malays by another party in power, say under Onn or Burhanuddin or Boestaman. There would be nothing to stop...
Read more...

CommentaryDo we really know what is a Social Contract?

article thumbnailJean-Jacques Rousseau believed that the liberty of the indivdual and the moral legitimacy of government could be achieved if and only if humanity entered into a “social contract". The instantiation of this pact was said to create a single...
Read more...

More...

Politics

PoliticsMahathir: Pencalonan UMNO

article thumbnail Kenapakah UMNO dan rakyat lain hendakkan peralihan kuasa lebih awal? Apakah kerana tidak suka kepada tubuh badan Abdullah atau apakah kerana tidak suka kepada dasar-dasar dan pendekatannya dalam pentadbiran parti dan Negara? Apakah kerana mereka...
Read more...

PoliticsDo voters appreciate responsive government?

article thumbnailVoters punish politicians following adverse weather events, but the degree of punishment depends critically on the quality of the ruling party's response: Those distributing greater amounts of relief aid suffer smaller subsequent electoral losses.
Read more...

PoliticsMahathir: Racism and 2008 election

article thumbnailTruly Malaysian politics have not been decoupled from racial sentiments and loyalties. And it is going to remain so for as long as the different races prefer to be separated and divided, prefer to strongly uphold their languages, cultures and their...
Read more...

PoliticsIslam sebagai agama bagi Persekutuan: Rakyat dan sistem pemerintahannya mesti seiring

article thumbnail ...tidak ada kesalahan yang lebih besar bagi rakyat selain menolak Perlembagaan negara. Di Malaysia, antara contoh kesalahan ‘dosa besar’ adalah menyentuh atau mempertikai kedudukan raja-raja Melayu. Apa yang sepatutnya berlaku adalah...
Read more...

More...

Voices

VoicesMinister answer please on Malaysia Apex University, VCs

article thumbnail The highly-educated officials in charge of Malaysia's tertiary education, have not yet eradicated gender inequalities embedded within the system. If Malaysia's decision-makers, fifty years post-independence, still have such a parochial mindset,...
Read more...

VoicesResponse: Perak MB says he did not seize camera

article thumbnail I am no fan of PKR. But I think sometimes reporters deserved it. In my dealings with them, some are uncouth, annoying and sorely lacking in finesse. Some don't know nuts about issues at hand. Don't do their homework. Sorely lacking in knowledge....
Read more...

VoicesSajak Kematian dan Fatwa Pengkid: Malaysia memang negara yang memeningkan

article thumbnail''Ini merupakan perkara yang tidak betul (rakaman keadaan azab) dan ia perbuatan penceramah yang ingin mencari 'makan'," katanya di sini hari ini... mengulas mengenai fatwa pengharaman pengkid, Dr. Asri berkata pengharaman pengkid oleh Majlis...
Read more...

VoicesSuara rakyat: Antara dua darjat

article thumbnail Ahmad Ismail diiktiraf Pendekar Melayu dengan disarungkan tengkolok kuning, selempang kuning dan keris kuning sebagai lambang keperkasaannya. Komen - beberapa penggal Ahmad Ismail jadi ketua Bahagian UMNO, lihat lah bagaimana masyarakat melayu...
Read more...

More...

Biz

Biz NewsHow Best to Put Natural Assets at the Top of the International Political Agenda

article thumbnail Meanwhile many experts believe that an intergovernmental panel or platform could provide early warning of biologically-related developments of regional or global significance years in advance of their public emergence. Some experts cite the case...
Read more...

Biz NewsEconomy Collapse: Stunned Icelanders Struggle

article thumbnail Emboldened by the strong krona, once-frugal Icelanders took regular shopping weekends in Europe, bought fancy cars and built bigger houses paid for with low-interest loans in foreign currencies... Like the Vikings of old, Icelandic bankers were...
Read more...

Biz NewsStimulus package is good but more need to be done

article thumbnail Pumping money into the system is better than just reducing the interest rate. Basically the stimulus package will stimulate construction and will create the multiply effects of upstream and downstream activities. The reduction of EPF contribution...
Read more...

Biz NewsGlobal-is-Asian: Asian diaspora identities in the context of globalization

article thumbnailHow do neoliberal economic reforms accompanying globalization and the emergence of various Asian countries as global powers shape interactions between Asian immigrant entrepreneurs and local populations? In the context of shifting global economies,...
Read more...

More...

Need help to promote your business?

Get VideoAd

Cast your net wider to reach more customers!

Contact us now: CLICK HERE

VideoAd with Cleat & Clew Communication
 

 

list4_custom.jpg

Got something to say?

We welcome your articles, blog links or Letter to the Editor via email to: This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

To complain about flaming comments, email to: This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

To advertise with us, please send your contact details via email to: This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

TalkBox

Latest Message: 1 day, 5 hours ago
  • Life Malaysia : 20/11: Abdul Razak Baginda says DPM Najib and wife Rosmah did not know or meet murdered Mongolian interpreter Altantuya Sharibuu/The Sun
  • Life Malaysia : 20/11: Political analyst Abdul Razak Baginda says DPM Dato' Seri Najib Tun Razak had never met murdered Mongolian Altantuya Sharibuu./Star
  • bananachinese : 19/11: Malaysia, New Zealand, Japan, South Korea, Singapore are most connected Asia Pacific countries with 55-80% having access to internet by 2007, says UN agency/The Star
  • Life Malaysia : Question: Does a minister resign from cabinet if he only submit the letter to his political party President? Go here for take on Ong Ka Chuan's 'resignation' «link»
  • Life Malaysia : 17/11: Petrol price reduced by 15 sen a litre effective 18 Nov. New price for RON97 is RM2/lt, RON92 at RM1.90 and diesel at RM1.90
  • mylivingwall : The automatic issuance of manufacturing licence exclude activities related to security, health, environment, religion/The Star
  • mylivingwall : 14/11: MITI says Automatic issuance for manufacturing licenses from Dec 1; full import duty exemption on raw materials and intermediate goods/Bernama
  • mylivingwall : 14/11: Police operation starts on Monday to nab 96,000 traffic offenders who were issued warrants of arrest fm May 1 to Oct 31 this year/The Sun
  • Cassandra : Eh, correction, only for AirAsia destinations, not include AirAsia X  oops
  • Cassandra : AirAsia removes all fuel surcharges from midnite today and offering 500,000 free seats to all AirAsia and AirAsia X destinations!!! Quickly everybody !!!
Please Login to shout..

Login Form






Enter what you see:
This image contains a scrambled text, it is using a combination of colors, font size, background, angle in order to disallow computer to automate reading. You will have to reproduce it to post on my homepage

Tips: Reload if you cant read the image
Lost Password?
No account yet? Register